K-pop and Korean entertainment from Korean fans' perspective

What's the standard of 'decent idol singing'?

Pann: What's the standard of 'decent idol singing'?

1. [+78, -71] Gongchan is decent? I can barely hear his voice

2. [+72, -1] People say an idol is decent if they're able to sing their parts but that's not being decent, that's the minimal task they have to do. An idol is considered decent if they can sing a full song without sounding annoying in any way. But the standard is ambiguous.

3. [+51, -20] Do I have a low standard? I thought of Xiumin, B.Bomb, and Gongchan.

4. [+31, -2] I think Key and Bomi are good, not decent. Some say Sungjae but all BTOB members are above decent. I think it's Jinyoung, L, Hayoung, and Sojin.

5. [+30, -6] Bigbang, TVXQ, JYJ, Mamamoo, and BTOB are above decent. The worst B2ST and B1A4 can do is still decent.

6. [+29, -3] An idol wouldn't be shameless if they're like God Junsu, Taeyang, Jonghyun, Sandeul, Yoseob, Changsub, and etc ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

7. [+28, -19] The three EXO members have absolutely no solution ㅋㅋㅋㅋ I'm not interested in EXO so I didn't understand the criticisms towards their singing but their MR removed versions said it all ㅋㅋㅋㅋ The three members are... ugh.

8. [+27, -3] You don't need to define the standard. The real singers are Yoseob, Eunji, Sandeul, Luna, and Taeyeon. What's the point of defining it?

9. [+27, -8] Bomi and Key are considered good among idols. I honestly think every idol should be able to sing a full song, but the majority of idols can't sing a full song perfectly without the main vocalists... The standard got lower eventually. I think Jungkook is considered decent.

10. [+25, -4] Hyeri is definitely the worst

11. [+23, -1] If an idol is without the main vocalist but they're able to sing the main vocalist's parts

12. [+20, -1] Jinyoung and Xiumin for male idols. Hayoung, Joy, and Lee Mijoo for female idols.

13. [+18, -1] Joy can't sing. It's not known because of her good voice. Know the reality.

14. [+14, -7] Why are people mentioning Joy? Seulgi is considered decent. Joy can't sing, she's just not mentioned. Her live singing has no solution.

Back To Top