Haeun - Shin Yong Jae
*Haeun is the artist and Shin Yong Jae is the name of the song
The song was released on Nov 6 and it failed to chart-in on the weekly chart in the first & second weeks
On the third week, it started charting on the weekly chart
Fourth week
Fifth week
Sixth week
Its Youtube views are 2.63M. Songs listened by non-fans have high Youtube views and his views are not comparable to his chart rank.
Yoon Jong Shin's 'Like It' started charting #69
His song started getting big and he charts much higher
On the third week, he's #15
On the fourth week, he's #6
However, Haeun's 'Shin Yong Jae' started charting #16 on the third week
On the second week, he's already #4
Haeun's agency has artists including Ben
=
Instiz: Another release that Melon seems to be manipulating after Ben
- They take us for fools ㅋㅋ
- Jang Deok Cheol, Nilo, and Shaun became more issued and they didn't get any punishment. So I think artists are starting to manipulate more and more...
- 4Men, Vibe, and Ben are already famous artists. I don't understand why they're trying to increase their digital results.
- JangNilShaun must be this company's role model
- If you accuse anyone of sajaegi, people are gonna call you an insecure idol fan
Article: Ben, "I cried because I charted #1 for the first time in 9 years since debut, Yoon Min Soo sent me a congratulating text"
Source: Sports Today via Nate
1. [+469, -45] Does she not know about the controversy or is she pretending to not know?
2. [+426, -40] Her graph was the same as Nilo, Shaun and Jang Deok Cheol's, though? Also her boyfriend is in the same agency as the three artists ㅋㅋ
3. [+345, -38] Didn't she do sajaegi?
4. [+100, -8] Rather than a sajaegi, it must be true that she must've paid a company to stream her song with multiple accounts. Ben's song became #1 between 12PM~2AM and the song was #1 during the entire dawn. If you know about the Melon chart, you'd know that it's impossible. Even a massive hit song can't beat boy group fandom's streaming at dawn. Popular female artists like IU and Jennie chart low at dawn and start rising in the morning. Unless it's a boy group, everybody should be charting low at that time. If she managed to beat them all and chart #1, it means that she must have more fans than the boy groups. Do you think it's true? I don't see the point of charting #1 by doing this. Maybe she thought people wouldn't be suspicious because she's more famous than Shaun and Jang Deok Cheol. I'm very disappointed. I used to like Ben's songs but she was blinded by short-term results and gained a flaw that will follow her for the rest of her career.
5. [+67, -11] Her song isn't even good to be charting #1...
6. [+66, -2] I didn't want to be suspicious but her graph was the same as Shaun and Jang Deok Cheol's. It doesn't make sense that she's charting higher at dawn.
7. [+60, -2] She's pretending like she doesn't know ㅋㅋ
8. [+55, -3] Her boyfriend must've wanted to make her happy ㅎㅎ Great boyfriend she got!
